A Brush with Controversy: The Saga of Tretchikoff's Lost Orchid

A Brush with Controversy: The Saga of Tretchikoff's Lost Orchid

Back in 2009, the art world was ablaze with controversy following the sale of Vladimir Tretchikoff's Lost Orchid painting at famed the Brett Kebble auction, which raised significant doubts about the artwork's authenticity. Initially celebrated for its record sale of R2.9 million, the painting's legitimacy came under scrutiny when discrepancies surfaced between the auctioned piece and an image published in Howard Timmins's 1969 book.

The auctioneer responsible for managing Kebble's collection, took immediate action, temporarily halting the sale to delve into the painting's authenticity. The inconsistencies observed between the two depictions, including nuanced details like the presence of a burnt match and the positioning of a teardrop on the orchid's petal, triggered meticulous scrutiny.

The auction house was unwavering in his commitment to preserving the auction's credibility, initiating a comprehensive investigation. This encompassed a range of analyses, from forensic tests to academic evaluations and an extensive exploration of Tretchikoff's artistic techniques. The peculiar signature discrepancy, with the letters "f" struck through, added a layer of skepticism surrounding the painting's authenticity.

However, despite the success of the auction and the painting's momentous sale, doubts about its origin and historical background began to surface, casting shadows on its provenance. The auctioneer sought to defend the plausibility of multiple versions of the same artwork, citing Tretchikoff's penchant for revisiting subjects and subtly altering his creations, akin to the practices observed in masters like Monet.

The narrative around the painting grew even more complex with conflicting reports and inquiries. A surprising and embarrassing incident unfolded at a prestigious art gallery, where a Tretchikoff painting initially believed to be Lost Orchid was later identified as a different artwork titled 'After the Party'. This error in cataloging led to the unintended sale of the painting at the auction, compounding the confusion.

Despite initial forensic analyses leaning toward affirming the painting's authenticity, ongoing investigations spearheaded by art experts, combined with extensive archival research and contradictory testimonies, threw the definitive validation of the artwork into uncertainty.

This intricate narrative, swirling around Tretchikoff's Lost Orchid painting, underscored the complexities inherent in the realm of art authentication. It highlights the significance of meticulous scrutiny in safeguarding and preserving the integrity of artistic heritage. As the investigation unfolded, an air of uncertainty loomed over the fate of this celebrated artwork, leaving the art community and collectors eagerly anticipating a resolution to this captivating saga.

The eventual conclusion of this investigation labelled the work as an original. Not  only impacting the value of the artwork but also serving as a testament to the diligence required in unraveling the intricate histories woven into masterpieces, ultimately ensuring the preservation of the rich legacy of renowned artists like Vladimir Tretchikoff.

Back to blog